Sitting on the Sidelines: The Hidden Price of Waiting for Better Housing Markets

Should You Wait for Housing Prices to Drop? Here's What the Numbers Actually Say

A lot of people are doing the same thing right now: sitting tight, watching the housing market, and hoping prices will eventually come down enough to make buying feel reasonable again. It's an understandable impulse. Nobody wants to overpay for the biggest purchase of their life. But here's the thing—Oxford Economics, one of the most respected economic research firms on the planet, just crunched the numbers on how long that wait might actually take.

Their answer? Seven years.

That's not a casual estimate or a wild guess. Oxford Economics does economic modeling for governments and major financial institutions worldwide. When they say housing affordability won't see meaningful improvement until around 2033, that's based on serious data about how prices, mortgage rates, and income levels would all need to shift simultaneously.

If you're thinking about whether to keep waiting or start looking at homes now, you need to understand what that seven-year timeline actually means for you—and what it costs you to wait. 

I have never worried about that. If it was time to buy, we bought. We dealt with the market as it was at the time. And over the years of moving up from house to house, we have been able to afford the house of our dreams. Had we waited because of prices or interest rates, we probably wouldn't be where we are now. And I even lost money on one home purchase, but that was because of divorce.

The Affordability Question Is More Complicated Than It Looks

When most people say they're waiting for housing to become "more affordable," they really mean they want prices to drop. That makes sense on the surface. Lower prices equal lower costs, right?

Except it's not that simple. Three things determine whether you can actually afford a home:

• Home prices. What sellers are asking and what people are paying.
• Mortgage rates. How much interest you're paying on the loan, which affects your monthly payment way more than you might think.
• Income. What you and other buyers actually earn, which determines how much house you can realistically afford.

All three of these have to move in the right direction at the same time for affordability to actually improve. And that's where the puzzle gets tricky.

Here's a real example of how it doesn't always work out the way people expect: Imagine prices stay flat, but mortgage rates stay elevated. Your monthly payment barely budges, even though prices didn't jump. Or flip it around - rates drop, which sounds great, but then more buyers jump back into the market because borrowing feels cheaper. With limited inventory, prices climb to match the new demand. Your monthly payment ends up in roughly the same place it was before. And that creates a seller's market like we had some years back, where some buyers overpaid so much they have zero equity.

Oxford Economics' seven-year projection takes all of this into account. Their research doesn't just look at what needs to happen to prices. It looks at the whole system - prices, rates, and income growth - and asks what it realistically takes for the typical household to afford a typical home again.

The answer they came up with: significant price corrections need to happen alongside sustained rate decreases and real income growth. And none of those conditions are happening right now, or showing signs of happening soon. But the skeptic in me can't help being puzzled at how this is going to magically happen in seven years.

What Seven Years Actually Means

That 2033 timeline can feel abstract. So let's get specific about what you're actually waiting for.

You're waiting for prices to come down meaningfully. Not stabilize - actually come down. In most markets, that hasn't happened in decades, and when it does happen, it's usually during a recession or major economic shock. Those aren't exactly things you want to root for.

You're waiting for mortgage rates to drop significantly. Rates are influenced by federal policy and broader economic conditions, and there's no guarantee they'll fall to pre-pandemic levels anytime soon. Even if they do, you're banking on timing the market perfectly, which is incredibly hard to do.

You're waiting for household incomes to grow faster than housing costs. This one is maybe the most important, because it's what actually determines whether a typical family can afford a home. Income growth has been steady but slow in most places.

All three things need to happen together. Not almost together. Together. And Oxford Economics says the realistic timeline for that is around 2033. I hope I remember this post 7 years down the line so I can see if Oxford Ecomonics was correct.

The Hidden Costs of Waiting

Here's what makes waiting tricky: it feels like a neutral decision. You're not doing anything, so nothing is costing you, right? Wrong.

Every year you wait instead of buying, two things are quietly working against you.

First, you're not building equity

When you own a home and make a mortgage payment, part of that payment goes toward interest (which goes to the bank), and part goes toward principal (which builds your ownership stake). Over time, as you pay down the principal, you own more and more of the house. That's equity, and it's real money.

We were lucky enough to buy two homes that gave us immediate, or almost immediate, equity. One was a foreclosure we bought at a low price and we worked on it immediately. We lived in it for 9 years, so the equity started out quickly and continued to grow over the years. The second home was our current one. We made our purchase when the crazy seller's market was just starting to gain steam. Although the home appraised $15,000 lower than the purchase price, the equity that occurred in the next 3 years was huge.

Second, rent isn't getting cheaper

When you rent, every single dollar goes to your landlord. None of it comes back to you. You're not building any ownership stake. You're just paying for the right to live somewhere for another month.

While you're waiting for housing prices to drop, rent is actually going up. The average renter is paying significantly more today than they were two or three years ago. If you're renting now and waiting for better buying conditions, you're paying more money every year, and you have nothing to show for it.

Let's say you wait two years for prices to drop. In that time, you might pay $30,000 or $40,000 or $50,000 in rent, depending on where you live. That money is gone. Meanwhile, someone who bought a house two years ago has paid down their mortgage principal and built equity, even if the home value hasn't budged.

The gap between the renter and the homeowner gets bigger every year.

The Rate-Drop Trap

A lot of waiting buyers are counting on mortgage rates to drop. That's their main hope for affordability to improve. And rates probably will drop at some point - they always do eventually.

But here's what usually happens when rates fall: more people realize they can qualify for a mortgage again, or can afford a higher price. They all jump back into the market at the same time. Demand shoots up. Sellers see increased interest and raise their prices because they know buyers are suddenly ready to bid. Again, back to the crazy Seller's Market that happened some years back. Only lucky buyers were able to purchase a house they loved. Some buyers simply gave up and stayed in their too small homes or continued renting.

In a market where there aren't many homes for sale (which is most markets right now), prices tend to climb pretty quickly once demand increases. So you end up in a situation where rates drop, prices rise, and your monthly payment stays about the same or barely improves. You waited years for something that doesn't actually help you.

This isn't theory. It's a predictable pattern that happens over and over in real estate markets.

So What Should You Actually Do?

The Oxford Economics projection is worth knowing about. Seven years is genuinely a long time, and if affordability doesn't improve on that timeline, waiting would have cost you a lot, both in rent paid and equity not built. But a national seven-year projection doesn't tell you what's right for your specific situation.

The real question isn't "Will housing affordability improve by 2033?" The real question is "What does buying or renting look like for me and my family this year, with actual numbers attached?"

That requires looking at your local market specifically - not national trends, but what homes actually cost where you live. It requires looking at local rental prices and how they compare to a mortgage payment. It requires understanding your own financial situation: how much you have saved for a down payment, what your credit looks like, whether you're stable in your job, how long you plan to stay in one place.

A home is typically the biggest purchase you'll make in your life. It shouldn't be based on hoping that national trends move in your favor over seven years. It should be based on your actual numbers, your actual timeline, and what makes sense for you right now.

If you've been waiting and haven't actually done the math on what a purchase would look like in your local market with your specific finances, that's worth doing. Not to pressure you into buying, but just to make sure you're making a decision based on reality instead of hope.

The waiting strategy has real costs. It's worth understanding those costs before you decide how much longer to stay on the sidelines. I can help you find out if you should continue waiting, or if maybe now is the right time to buy. Call me at 480-906-1500.

Tags

• housing prices (1)
• real estate prices (1)